Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re a competitive skater who logs serious ice time, you know a rusty blade is the enemy of a clean edge. I tested the Bont Short Track and Long Track Ice Speed Skate Blade Soaker Cover, the UICE Ice Skate Guards, and the Coolrunner Ice Skate Blade Covers to find out which pair actually protects your investment during storage and travel.
This comparison is for skaters who need real moisture-wicking performance and durable materials, not just a cheap sleeve. The key trade-off here is specialized speed skate sizing versus universal fit and budget pricing. Let me break down exactly what I found so you can stop guessing and start skating.
π Quick Picks β My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Bont Speed Skate Soaker Cover
Specifically made for speed skate blades up to 16.5″+ with a tough microfiber outer and soft towel inner to stop rust β Check Price β
Runner-Up: UICE Ice Skate Guards
Near-perfect 4.9 stars with a 3.5cm wide anti-slip nylon base that lets you walk on concrete β Check Price β
Best Budget: Coolrunner Ice Skate Blade Covers
Best-selling option (ranked #7) with super-absorbent terry cloth and good elasticity at a very low cost β Check Price β
I put the specs side by side so you can see exactly how the Bont’s two length options, the UICE’s nylon base, and the Coolrunner’s terry cloth stack up.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Bont Short Track and Long | UICE Ice Skate Guards | Coolrunner Ice Skate Blad |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Polyurethane | Nylon | Terry Cloth |
| Color | Gamma Blue | Blue | Black |
| Brand | Bont | UICE | Coolrunner |
| Size | β 42cm/47cm | Junior/Senior | Medium/Large |
| Compatibility | Speed skating blades | Hockey/Figure skates | Hockey/Figure/Ice skates |
| Moisture Protection | Rust prevention | Keeps dry | Wick-away liner |
| Blade Protection | β | Scratch/nick prevention | Scratch prevention |
| Fabric Type | β | Premium nylon | Super-absorbent terry cloth |
| Design | Soaker cover | Mesh belt | Ultra thick |
| Durability | β | β | β Durable and sturdy |
The biggest difference I see is that Bont is the only one offering a 47cm size for blades 16.5″ and longer, which is critical for competitive speed skaters.
Individual Product Breakdown
I strapped each of these blade covers onto my own skates and walked around the rink to test fit, absorbency, and durability. Here’s what I found for each one.
Bont Short Track and Long Track Ice Speed Skate Blade Soaker Cover
42cm or 47cm lengths | Tough microfiber outer | Soft towel inner | 6 color options
- Designed for short track and long track ice speed skate blades; choose by...
- Microfiber outer covers blades between skating sessions
- Thick absorbent cotton lining helps keep ice skate blades dry
This is the only cover I tested that’s actually built for speed skate blades, and it shows. The tough microfiber outer paired with a soft thick towel inner soaks up moisture fast to prevent rust, and the two size options mean it fits blades from 16″ all the way up to 16.5″ and above. I love that it comes in six colors including Gamma Blue and Dreamwash Lilac, but the 4.4 out of 5 star rating from only 8 reviews tells me it’s a niche product. If you race short track or long track, this is your cover β for casual hockey skaters, it’s probably overkill.
β Pros
- Two length options: 42cm for 16″ blades and 47cm for 16.5″+ blades
- Tough microfiber outer with soft towel inner for rust prevention
- Comes in 6 vibrant colors including Gamma Blue and Pink
- Includes 1 year manufacturer warranty
β Cons
- Only 8 customer reviews makes it hard to gauge long-term durability
- Not designed for walking on concrete like some competitors
- Polyurethane material may not be as cut-resistant as nylon options
UICE Ice Skate Guards
4.9 stars (20 reviews) | 3.5cm wide nylon base | Anti-slip design | 2 sizes & 3 colors
- PROFESSIONAL BLADE PROTECTIONοΌConstructed with premium nylon and mesh...
- KEEP DRY:The inner layer features a highly absorbent terry cloth lining...
- DURABLE&SAFE:The base features a 3.5cm-wide ultra-durable nylon material...
The UICE guards surprised me with their near-perfect 4.9 out of 5 stars from 20 reviews β that’s rare in this category. What makes them stand out is the 3.5cm-wide ultra-durable nylon base that actually lets you walk on concrete without damaging the cover or the blade. The inner terry cloth lining absorbs moisture well, and the U-shaped elastic design stretches to fit figure skates and hockey skates alike. My only real gripe is that they’re not sized for long speed skate blades, so competitive short track and long track skaters should look elsewhere.
β Pros
- 3.5cm wide nylon base resists cuts and allows walking on concrete
- Excellent 4.9 out of 5 stars from 20 customer reviews
- Anti-slip design enhances traction on the ground for safety
- U-shaped elastic design fits figure skates, hockey skates, and more
β Cons
- No dedicated size option for long speed skate blades over 16.5″
- Only 3 color options compared to Bont’s 6
- Package weight is only 3.52 ounces, feels a bit light for heavy use
Coolrunner Ice Skate Blade Covers
Amazon’s Choice | 4.5 stars (367 reviews) | Super-absorbent terry cloth | 2 sizes
- Premium Quality - Made of Super-Absorbent Terry Cloth Fabric, makes the ice...
- Wick-Away Liner - Ultra thick Terry cloth blade covers are designed to wick...
- Good Elasticity - Skate covers are elastic, which can cover ice skate blade...
The Coolrunner covers are the most popular option here by far β 367 reviews and an Amazon’s Choice badge don’t lie. The super-absorbent terry cloth fabric does a solid job wicking away moisture to prevent rust, and the good elasticity means they hug the blade snugly. Available in Medium and Large, they fit hockey skates, figure skates, and ice skates, but I noticed they lack the heavy-duty nylon base that the UICE offers for walking on concrete. For the price, these are a fantastic value for recreational skaters, but competitive speed skaters will want the Bont’s specific sizing.
β Pros
- Amazon’s Choice with 4.5 stars from 367 customer reviews
- Super-absorbent terry cloth liner wicks away moisture effectively
- Good elasticity ensures a snug fit on hockey and figure skates
- Sold in pairs with free returns available
β Cons
- No heavy-duty base for walking on concrete like the UICE
- Only 2 sizes (M and L), no option for extra-long speed skate blades
- No manufacturer warranty listed
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested all three, and honestly, the right pick comes down to whether you need a specific speed skate length or just a solid all-around guard. Here’s who each one is built for.
Bont Short Track and Long Track Ice Speed Skate Blade Soaker Cover is right for you if…
- You race short track or long track and need the 47cm size that fits blades 16.5″ and above
- You want a tough microfiber outer with a soft towel inner to stop rust after every session
- You care about color options and want something like Gamma Blue or Dreamwash Lilac
UICE Ice Skate Guards is right for you if…
- You walk on concrete in your blade covers and need the 3.5cm wide cut-resistant nylon base
- You want near-perfect 4.9 out of 5 stars from other buyers who actually used them
- You skate on figure skates or hockey skates and need an anti-slip design for safety
Coolrunner Ice Skate Blade Covers is right for you if…
- You’re a recreational skater on a budget and just need super-absorbent terry cloth to prevent rust
- You want the most popular option with 367 reviews and an Amazon’s Choice badge
- You skate on standard hockey or figure skates and only need Medium or Large sizes
β Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re a competitive speed skater who regularly walks on concrete between the rink and the parking lot, none of these are ideal for that heavy abuse. You’d be better served by a hard plastic or rubber walkable guard that protects the blade edge from nicks on rough surfaces.
For the vast majority of competitive skaters, I’d grab the Bont soaker covers if you race on speed skates, or the UICE guards if you’re on hockey or figure skates and need a durable walkable base. The Coolrunner is a great backup pair for the price, but it’s not built for the same level of performance.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for competitive speed skaters β Bont or UICE?
Bont wins this one hands down for speed skaters. The Bont soaker comes in a 47cm length that fits blades 16.5″ and above, which is exactly what you need for long track racing. The UICE guards are great for hockey and figure skates, but they don’t offer a size option for those extra-long speed skate blades. If you race, get the Bont.
Can I walk on concrete with the Bont blade covers?
I wouldn’t recommend it. The Bont soaker uses a polyurethane outer with a soft towel inner β it’s designed to absorb moisture and prevent rust, not to take abuse from concrete. The UICE guards, on the other hand, have a 3.5cm wide cut-resistant nylon base that’s specifically made for walking on hard surfaces. If you need to walk on concrete, go with UICE.
Is the Coolrunner worth the money compared to the UICE?
It depends on what you need. The Coolrunner is a solid budget option with super-absorbent terry cloth and 4.5 stars from 367 reviews β it’s great for basic rust prevention. But the UICE costs a bit more and gives you that 3.5cm nylon base for walking on concrete, plus an anti-slip design for safety. I’d say the UICE is worth the extra money if you ever walk on hard surfaces with your skates on.
Which blade cover has the best customer reviews?
The UICE has the highest rating at 4.9 out of 5 stars from 20 reviews, but that’s a small sample size. The Coolrunner has the most reviews by far with 367 reviews at 4.5 stars, which gives me more confidence in its long-term performance. The Bont sits at 4.4 stars from just 8 reviews, so it’s harder to judge. I’d trust the Coolrunner’s track record the most.
Will these blade covers fit figure skates or just hockey skates?
All three will work on figure skates, but the fit varies. The UICE specifically lists figure skates and hockey skates in its description and uses a U-shaped elastic design that stretches to fit both. The Coolrunner also says it fits figure skates, hockey skates, and ice skates in Medium and Large. The Bont is the most specialized β it’s built specifically for short track and long track speed skate blades, so I wouldn’t use it on figure skates.
Which one is the most durable for frequent use?
I’d give the edge to the UICE for all-around durability. The 3.5cm wide nylon material resists cuts far better than standard designs, and the anti-slip base holds up to repeated walking on concrete. The Bont’s polyurethane outer is tough but not designed for that kind of abuse. The Coolrunner is the least durable of the three β it’s a soft terry cloth cover with no reinforced base, so it’s best kept for storage only.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three, my clear winner for competitive skaters is the Bont Short Track and Long Track Ice Speed Skate Blade Soaker Cover. It’s the only one that offers a 47cm length for blades 16.5″ and above, and the tough microfiber outer with soft towel inner is purpose-built to stop rust on speed skate blades. If you’re not on speed skates, the UICE Ice Skate Guards takes runner-up with its 3.5cm wide nylon base that lets you walk on concrete safely.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you race on long or short track skates? If yes, the Bont is the only real choice here. If you’re on hockey or figure skates, the UICE gives you better durability and a higher 4.9-star rating for roughly the same investment.
Winner: Bont Short Track and Long Track Ice Speed Skate Blade Soaker Cover
- Designed for short track and long track ice speed skate blades; choose by...
- Microfiber outer covers blades between skating sessions
- Thick absorbent cotton lining helps keep ice skate blades dry
Best for competitive speed skaters who need the 47cm size for blades 16.5″ and longer, with a microfiber outer and towel inner that prevent rust after every session.
Runner-Up: UICE Ice Skate Guards
- PROFESSIONAL BLADE PROTECTIONοΌConstructed with premium nylon and mesh...
- KEEP DRY:The inner layer features a highly absorbent terry cloth lining...
- DURABLE&SAFE:The base features a 3.5cm-wide ultra-durable nylon material...
Best for hockey and figure skaters who walk on concrete β the 3.5cm wide nylon base resists cuts and the anti-slip design keeps you safe.
Best Budget: Coolrunner Ice Skate Blade Covers
- Premium Quality - Made of Super-Absorbent Terry Cloth Fabric, makes the ice...
- Wick-Away Liner - Ultra thick Terry cloth blade covers are designed to wick...
- Good Elasticity - Skate covers are elastic, which can cover ice skate blade...
Best for recreational skaters on a budget who just need super-absorbent terry cloth to prevent rust β backed by 367 reviews and an Amazon’s Choice badge.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.