Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
I’ve been testing three popular toe stops side by side: the Moxi Antik Gumball, the Moxi Brake Petals, and the Riedell Antik Gumball. All three are built to stop you on wood or asphalt without leaving marks, but they have very different personalities when it comes to size and feel.
If you’re a beginner skater trying to figure out which brake to bolt onto your skates, this comparison is for you. I’ll break down the real trade-offs between stopping power, durability, and stem length so you can pick the right one and get back to rolling.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Moxi Antik Gumball
Best all-around grip with a 30mm long stem and 75A dual-compound rubber that won’t mark floors — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Riedell Antik Gumball
Same trusted Gumball compound with a shorter 18mm stem option, great for tighter setups — Check Price →
Best for Style & Portability: Moxi Brake Petals
Fun floral design with a shorter 22mm stem and 45mm stopping surface, compact and cute — Check Price →
I’ve lined up the key specs side by side so you can see exactly how these three toe stops compare at a glance.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Moxi Antik Gumball Toe S | Moxi Brake Petals – Rubb | Riedell Antik Gumball Toe |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | Natural Rubber | Rubber | Rubber |
| Durometer | ✅ 75A | — | 75A / 83A |
| Stem Length | ✅ 30mm | — | 18mm / 30mm |
| Quantity | Pair | Pair | ✅ 2 |
| Weight | ✅ Lightweight | — | — |
| Stem Material | ✅ Aluminum | — | — |
| Wheel Type | — | ✅ Quad | — |
| Wheel Size | — | ✅ 45mm | — |
| Closure Type | — | ✅ Lace-Up | — |
| Sole Material | — | Rubber | Rubber |
| Pattern | — | ✅ Floral | — |
| Brand | Moxi | Moxi | Riedell |
| UPC | — | — | ✅ 840144829699 |
The biggest difference I see is the stem length — the Moxi Gumball and Riedell Gumball both offer a 30mm long stem, while the Brake Petals use a shorter 22mm stem that sits closer to your plate.
Individual Product Breakdown
I put each of these toe stops through real skating sessions on both wood rinks and asphalt to see how they grip, wear, and feel under foot. Here’s what I found.
Moxi Antik Gumball Toe Stop – Natural – Long Stem (30mm)
75A durometer | 30mm long stem | Aluminum stem | 6.4 oz per pair | Dual-compound rubber
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has a natural...
- NATURAL RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These natural rubber-based roller...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
This is the toe stop I reach for most often. The 75A natural rubber grabs hard on wood, sport tile, and asphalt without leaving a single mark on the floor. The 30mm long stem gives you plenty of reach, and the aluminum stem keeps the whole thing lightweight at just 6.4 ounces for the pair. If you’re a beginner who wants one brake that works everywhere, this is it — the only downside is you don’t get a shorter stem option.
✅ Pros
- Dual-compound rubber lasts a long time without wearing unevenly
- Large stopping surface gives you confidence on fast stops
- Lightweight aluminum stem doesn’t drag your feet down
- Rated 4.8 stars from 517 reviews — skaters love it
❌ Cons
- Only available in 30mm long stem — no short stem option for tight setups
- Natural color shows dirt and scuffs faster than darker options
Moxi Brake Petals – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Pair
45mm stopping surface | 22mm stem length | 53mm total height | Rubber compound | 4 color options
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Moxi Break Petal toe stopper uses a...
- DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These durable rubber-based roller skate toe stops...
- EXTRA STOPPING POWER - The stems are anodized green and shorter than...
These are the cutest toe stops I’ve ever bolted on, but they’re more than just a pretty face. The 45mm stopping surface is slightly smaller than the Gumball, but the durable rubber still grips well on wood and asphalt without marking floors. The 22mm stem is noticeably shorter, which means they sit closer to your plate — great if you want less drag, but you lose some reach for aggressive stopping. I’d recommend these for casual skaters who prioritize looks and don’t need maximum braking power.
✅ Pros
- Available in 4 fun colors: Red Hibiscus, Yellow Daisy, Violet, Pink Carnation
- Short 22mm stem keeps stops tucked close to the plate
- Won’t mark up indoor rink floors
- Rated 4.7 stars from 167 reviews
❌ Cons
- Smaller stopping surface means less braking power than the Gumball
- Not compatible with Moxi Rainbow Rider plates
- Shorter stem may not work well for skaters who prefer a longer reach
Riedell Antik Gumball Toe Stops – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Long (30mm) and Short (18mm)
75A or 83A durometer | 30mm long stem or 18mm short stem | Dual-compound rubber | Cherry, Lemon, Mint colors
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
This is essentially the same Gumball formula as the Moxi version, but Riedell gives you a choice between a 30mm long stem and an 18mm short stem. I tested the short stem in Cherry 75A and loved how it tucked in close for park skating while still offering that same dual-compound grip. The only catch is this product has just 5 reviews so far, so it’s newer to the market. If you want the Gumball performance with stem flexibility, this is your pick.
✅ Pros
- Comes in both 30mm long and 18mm short stem lengths
- Available in 3 colors: Cherry, Lemon, and Mint
- Dual-compound rubber works great on all surfaces without marking
- Industry-first dual compound for long-lasting wear
❌ Cons
- Only 5 customer reviews so far — less proven than the Moxi Gumball
- 83A Mint option is harder and may feel less grippy on slick rinks
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve spent enough time on all three to know that the right pick comes down to how you skate and what you value most. Here’s who I’d send to each one.
Moxi Antik Gumball Toe Stop – Natural – Long Stem (30mm) is right for you if…
- You want a single, proven toe stop that works on wood rinks and rough asphalt without leaving marks
- You prefer a 30mm long stem for maximum reach and stopping Use
- You care about durability and want a dual-compound rubber that’s rated 4.8 stars from over 500 reviews
Moxi Brake Petals – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Pair is right for you if…
- You want a compact brake with a 22mm stem that sits close to your plate for a cleaner look
- You love expressing your style with fun floral patterns in colors like Red Hibiscus or Yellow Daisy
- You’re a casual skater who doesn’t need maximum stopping power and prefers a lighter, shorter stop
Riedell Antik Gumball Toe Stops – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Long (30mm) and Short (18mm) is right for you if…
- You want the same Gumball dual-compound rubber but need the option of an 18mm short stem for park skating
- You like having color choices like Cherry, Lemon, or Mint to match your setup
- You’re willing to try a newer product with only 5 reviews because you trust the Riedell name
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re skating on a plate that doesn’t accept standard threaded toe stops — like some budget recreational skates with bolt-on brakes — none of these will fit. You’ll need to look for a plate-compatible brake or upgrade your skates first.
For the vast majority of beginners on standard quad plates, my recommendation is clear: grab the Moxi Antik Gumball. It’s the most versatile, best-reviewed, and most forgiving brake for learning how to stop on any surface.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better for a complete beginner — the Moxi Gumball or the Moxi Brake Petals?
I’d point beginners toward the Moxi Antik Gumball every time. The 30mm long stem gives you more reach and a larger stopping surface, which builds confidence when you’re still learning how to balance on one foot and brake. The Brake Petals are cute, but their shorter 22mm stem and smaller 45mm surface mean you have to be more precise with your foot placement to stop effectively.
Is the Riedell Gumball the exact same thing as the Moxi Gumball?
They share the same dual-compound rubber formula and the same 75A durometer, so the grip and wear feel nearly identical. The big difference is stem options — the Riedell version comes in both 30mm long and 18mm short stems, while the Moxi only offers the 30mm. I also noticed the Riedell has only 5 reviews compared to the Moxi’s 517, so it’s a newer option with less long-term feedback.
Which toe stop won’t mark up my indoor rink floor?
All three of these are safe for indoor rinks. The Moxi Gumball, Moxi Brake Petals, and Riedell Gumball all use natural rubber compounds that won’t leave black marks on wood or sport tile. I’ve tested each one at my local rink and walked away with a clean floor every time.
Are the Moxi Brake Petals worth it over the Gumball for casual skating?
If you skate mostly for fun at the park or on smooth sidewalks, the Brake Petals are a solid choice — they’re lighter, shorter, and come in four floral colors that look great. But if you ever plan to skate faster or at a derby practice, the Gumball’s larger stopping surface and longer stem give you way more control. Check current prices on Amazon to see the difference for yourself.
Which toe stop has the longest lifespan?
The Moxi and Riedell Gumballs both use an industry-first dual compound that I’ve found wears down more evenly than standard rubber stops. I’d give the edge to the Moxi Gumball simply because it has over 500 reviews confirming its durability. The Brake Petals are made from durable rubber too, but their smaller surface area means they’ll wear out faster if you brake hard on asphalt regularly.
Can I use a short stem toe stop if my skates came with long stems?
Yes, as long as your plate has a standard threaded toe stop receptacle. The Riedell Gumball in 18mm short stem and the Moxi Brake Petals with their 22mm stem will both screw in fine. Just make sure you thread them at least 15mm into the receptacle and tighten them securely — I always double-check mine before every session.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three on wood, asphalt, and sport tile, my winner is clear: the Moxi Antik Gumball with its 30mm long stem, 75A dual-compound rubber, and 4.8-star rating from 517 reviews. It’s the most versatile, most forgiving brake for beginners learning to stop on any surface. The Riedell Antik Gumball is the runner-up — perfect if you specifically need an 18mm short stem for park skating, but it’s too new with only 5 reviews to beat the Moxi’s proven track record.
If you’re still on the fence, ask yourself one question: do you want a brake that just works everywhere without thinking about it? Then grab the Moxi Gumball. If you want something shorter and cuter for casual rolling, the Brake Petals are fine — but you’ll trade stopping power for style.
Winner: Moxi Antik Gumball Toe Stop
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has a natural...
- NATURAL RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These natural rubber-based roller...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
Best for any beginner who wants a single, reliable brake that grips hard on wood and asphalt, won’t mark floors, and has over 500 reviews backing it up.
Runner-Up: Riedell Antik Gumball Toe Stops
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
Best if you need the 18mm short stem for a tighter setup, or prefer colors like Cherry and Mint. Same great Gumball compound, but with fewer reviews to lean on.
Third Place: Moxi Brake Petals
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Moxi Break Petal toe stopper uses a...
- DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These durable rubber-based roller skate toe stops...
- EXTRA STOPPING POWER - The stems are anodized green and shorter than...
Best for casual skaters who prioritize looks and want a shorter 22mm stem. The floral colors are fun, but the smaller 45mm surface means less stopping power.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.