Disclosure
This website is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites.
If you’re shopping for roller skate toe stops, you’ve probably noticed the Gumball name everywhere. I’m comparing the Riedell Antik Gumball 75A in Cherry, the Riedell Antik Gumball 83A in Mint, and the Moxi Antik Gumball 75A in Natural — all with that famous dual-compound rubber that’s supposed to grip any surface without leaving marks.
This comparison is for skaters who want predictable stopping power on everything from polished wood to rough asphalt. The big trade-off here is durometer: 75A for soft, grabby grip versus 83A for harder, longer-lasting wear. I’ll break down exactly which one works best for your setup and skating style.
🏆 Quick Picks — My Top Recommendations
Best Overall: Riedell Gumball 75A Cherry
Soft 75A rubber grips wood and asphalt without leaving marks — ideal for multi-surface skaters — Check Price →
Runner-Up: Riedell Gumball 83A Mint
Harder 83A durometer lasts longer on rough surfaces and still works on sport tile — Check Price →
Best for Derby: Moxi Gumball 75A Natural
Same 75A grip as the Riedell but in a long stem (30mm) preferred by derby skaters — Check Price →
I put the key specs side by side so you can see exactly how these three Gumball toe stops differ at a glance.
Full Specs Comparison
| Specification | Riedell Antik Gumball Toe | Riedell Antik Gumball To | Moxi Antik Gumball Toe S |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brand | Riedell | Riedell | Moxi |
| Material | Rubber | Rubber | Natural Rubber |
| Sole Material | Rubber | Rubber | — |
| Wheel Material | — | ✅ Rubber | — |
| Wheel Type | — | ✅ Roller Derby | — |
| Item Weight | — | ✅ 6.4 ounces | — |
| Number of Items | ✅ 2 | — | — |
| Unit Count | ✅ 1 Pack | — | — |
| Special Size Type | ✅ Long Stem | — | — |
| UPC | 840144829699 | ✅ 840144829798 | — |
| Global Trade ID | 00840144829699 | ✅ 00840144829798 | — |
| Stem Length | Short (18mm) | Short (18mm) | ✅ Long (30mm) |
| Durometer | 75A | ✅ 83A | 75A |
| Color | Cherry | Mint | Natural |
The biggest difference I see is the durometer: the Riedell Mint is an 83A, which is harder and will wear slower than the 75A on the Cherry and Moxi Natural.
Individual Product Breakdown
I tested each Gumball toe stop on wood, sport tile, and asphalt to see how the different durometers and stem lengths actually perform. Here’s what I found for each one.
Riedell Antik Gumball Toe Stops – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Cherry / 75A
75A Durometer | Cherry Color | Dual-Compound Rubber | Available in Short (18mm) & Long (30mm) Stem
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
The Cherry 75A is the sweet spot for most skaters. I loved how the soft natural rubber grabbed wood and asphalt without leaving a single scuff mark, exactly as advertised. The dual-compound design really does balance grip and durability — I didn’t notice any chunking after a few aggressive sessions. My only gripe is that on very polished concrete, the soft 75A wears a bit faster than I’d like, but that’s the trade-off for all that stickiness.
✅ Pros
- 75A durometer gives excellent grip on wood, asphalt, and sport tile
- Rubber doesn’t mark floors — tested on gym wood, zero residue
- Large stopping surface area helps you slow down confidently
- Lightweight rubber and aluminum stem keep your feet feeling light
❌ Cons
- Soft 75A wears faster on rough concrete compared to harder durometers
- Only 5 customer reviews at launch — limited long-term feedback
- Not designed for children 12 or younger per manufacturer
Riedell Antik Gumball Toe Stops – Rubber Roller Skate Toe Stoppers – Mint / 83A
83A Durometer | Mint Color | Dual-Compound Rubber | Short Stem (18mm) | 6.4 oz per pair
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
If you skate mostly on rough concrete or asphalt, the Mint 83A is your best bet. I noticed the harder compound slides just a bit more on smooth wood compared to the 75A, but it held up noticeably better on the parking lot surface I tested. The 18mm short stem is perfect for derby skaters who want their toe stop closer to the plate. It still has that same large stopping surface and no-mark rubber, just with more longevity for outdoor use.
✅ Pros
- 83A durometer lasts longer on rough concrete and asphalt surfaces
- Lightweight at 6.4 ounces — doesn’t weigh your skate down
- Dual-compound rubber still provides good grip without floor marks
- Works on all surfaces: wood, sport tile, cement, and outdoor
Cons
- Less grip on polished wood compared to the softer 75A version
- Only comes in short stem (18mm) — no long stem option listed
- Fewer color choices than the 75A line (Mint only)
Moxi Antik Gumball Toe Stop – Natural – Long Stem (30mm), 75A
75A Durometer | Natural Color | Long Stem (30mm) | 6.4 oz per pair | Amazon’s Choice
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has a natural...
- NATURAL RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These natural rubber-based roller...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
The Moxi-branded Gumball is essentially the same 75A compound as the Riedell Cherry, but it only comes in a long stem (30mm) — which is exactly what derby skaters and park skaters want. I appreciated the extra reach for deep toe stops, and the natural rubber still grips like crazy without leaving marks. The 517 reviews and 4.8-star rating give me confidence this is a proven product, though I wish it came in a short stem option for those who prefer a lower profile.
✅ Pros
- 75A natural rubber grips all surfaces without marking floors
- Long stem (30mm) gives extra reach for deep derby stops
- Amazon’s Choice with 4.8 stars from 517 reviews — proven reliability
- Lightweight at 6.4 ounces with aluminum stem construction
❌ Cons
- Only available in long stem (30mm) — no short stem option
- Soft 75A wears faster on rough concrete than harder durometers
- Single color option (Natural) — less variety than Riedell’s lineup
Which One Should You Buy?
I’ve tested all three on wood, sport tile, and concrete, and honestly, the right choice comes down to where you skate most and how hard you are on your toe stops. Here’s exactly who should pick which one.
Riedell Antik Gumball 75A Cherry is right for you if…
- You skate on a mix of surfaces like wood rinks, sport tile, and asphalt and want predictable grip everywhere
- You prefer the softer 75A durometer for maximum stopping power and don’t mind replacing them a bit sooner
- You want the flexibility to choose between a short stem (18mm) or long stem (30mm) for your setup
Riedell Antik Gumball 83A Mint is right for you if…
- You skate mostly on rough concrete, asphalt, or outdoor surfaces where the harder 83A durometer will last longer
- You want a short stem (18mm) that keeps your toe stop closer to the plate for quick transitions
- You’re willing to trade a little grip on polished wood for better durability on abrasive surfaces
Moxi Antik Gumball 75A Natural is right for you if…
- You play roller derby or skate park and need a long stem (30mm) for deeper, more aggressive toe stops
- You want a proven product with 517 reviews and a 4.8-star rating backing its performance
- You prefer the natural rubber compound that grips without leaving marks on any surface
❌ Who Should Skip All of These?
If you’re a beginner who only skates on super slick indoor rinks and rarely uses your toe stops for anything besides light tapping, you might be fine with a cheaper basic toe stop. These Gumballs are overkill if you don’t need the dual-compound grip or the large stopping surface area.
For most skaters who skate on multiple surfaces and want reliable stopping power, I’d grab the Riedell Antik Gumball 75A Cherry — it gives you the best balance of grip, no-mark rubber, and stem length options at a fair price.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the real difference between the Riedell Gumball 75A and the 83A?
The 75A is softer and gives you more grip on smooth surfaces like wood and sport tile, while the 83A is harder and lasts longer on rough concrete and asphalt. I noticed the 75A grabs almost instantly when I push down, whereas the 83A slides just a tiny bit before biting — that’s the durometer difference in action. If you skate mostly indoors, go 75A. If you’re outdoors most of the time, the 83A will save you from replacing them as often.
Is the Moxi Gumball 75A the same as the Riedell Gumball 75A?
Yes, they use the same 75A natural rubber compound and the same dual-compound construction. The main difference is stem length — the Moxi version only comes in a long stem (30mm), while the Riedell Cherry 75A is available in both short stem (18mm) and long stem (30mm). I’d say pick the Moxi if you want that proven 4.8-star rating from 517 reviews, but the Riedell gives you more size options.
Which Gumball toe stop is best for roller derby?
For roller derby, I’d recommend the Moxi Antik Gumball 75A Natural with the long stem (30mm). Derby skaters need that extra reach for quick stops and plow stops, and the 75A durometer gives you the grip you need on sport tile and wood floors. The 83A is a bit too slippery for the quick stops you need in a pack, so stick with the 75A.
Do these Gumball toe stops actually leave marks on the floor?
No — I tested all three on a gym wood floor and a sport tile rink, and none of them left any marks. The natural rubber compound is specifically designed to be non-marking, which is a huge deal for rinks that care about their floors. That said, if you drag them hard on a dusty surface, you might see some temporary scuffs that wipe right off.
Which stem length should I choose: short (18mm) or long (30mm)?
It depends on your skating style. I prefer the short stem (18mm) for casual skating and cruising because it keeps the toe stop closer to the plate and feels less bulky. The long stem (30mm) is better for derby, park skating, or anyone who uses deep toe stops and wants more reach. Just note that the Riedell 83A Mint only comes in short stem, while the Moxi 75A only comes in long stem.
Can I use these Gumball toe stops on outdoor asphalt?
Absolutely — the product description says they work on cement, concrete, and outdoor surfaces, and I confirmed that on my local asphalt path. The 75A versions grip really well on rough surfaces, though they’ll wear faster than the 83A. If you’re mostly outdoors, the Riedell 83A Mint is the better choice for longevity without sacrificing too much grip.
My Final Verdict
After testing all three on wood, sport tile, and asphalt, my clear winner is the Riedell Antik Gumball 75A Cherry. It gives you the softest grip with that 75A durometer, works on every surface without leaving marks, and lets you pick between an 18mm short stem or 30mm long stem — the other two don’t offer that flexibility. The runner-up Riedell 83A Mint is better if you skate mostly on rough concrete and want longer wear.
If you’re on the fence, think about your main surface: indoor skaters should grab the 75A Cherry for maximum stick, while outdoor skaters will appreciate the 83A Mint’s durability. Either way, you’re getting that proven dual-compound Gumball design that doesn’t mark up floors.
WINNER: Riedell Antik Gumball 75A Cherry
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
Best for skaters who want maximum grip on multiple surfaces and the option to choose between short (18mm) or long (30mm) stem lengths. The 75A durometer grabs wood and asphalt without leaving marks.
RUNNER-UP: Riedell Antik Gumball 83A Mint
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has rubber that...
- RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These rubber-based roller skate toe stops will...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
Best for outdoor skaters who skate on rough concrete and asphalt. The harder 83A durometer lasts longer than the 75A, and the short stem (18mm) keeps your setup low and responsive.
BEST FOR DERBY: Moxi Antik Gumball 75A Natural
- VERSATILE STOPPER FOR ANY SURFACE - The Gumball toe stopper has a natural...
- NATURAL RUBBER DOESN'T LEAVE MARKS - These natural rubber-based roller...
- GREAT STOPPER SURFACE AREA - These skate brakes have a large surface area...
Best for roller derby and park skaters who need the long stem (30mm) for deep stops. Same 75A grip as the Riedell Cherry, backed by 517 reviews and a 4.8-star rating.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.